Social Media Twitter Facebook Linked In RSS Feed Podcasts

Problems in regulation and governance

It all comes back to a certification system built on paper. Audits are mainly a paper trail, and field visits are planned in advance. These take priority over building farmer knowledge, while cost pressures on CBs mean they work as quickly as possible, may lack qualified staff, while competition means no one wants to risk going public with failure.

The problem is not individual CBs but the system design and a failure since 2008 to implement mass balance reconciliation.

Binay Kumar Choudhury and Robert Demianew, from the global certifier Control Union, told us there were many points of pressure in the system, with certification split between multiple bodies and standards. There are 32 farm level CBs with Control Union certifying perhaps only five to seven per cent of the total organic cotton farming.

From the gin, where the GOTS and TE standards start, upwards there are still 18 CBs as well as testing labs. GOTS’ approved labs depend on transaction certificates from other labs. This fragmented landscape of multiple bodies certifying only parts of the chain is a major opening for fraud and error.

“CBs are supposed to perform risk analyses based on transaction certificates,” Binay and Robert say, “but there are too many breaks in traceability.” This suggests there should be an open data registry to allow for full traceability.

But most sources agree whether all products are organic is still questionable.

Industry inaction?

Our source claims that GOTS, IOAS and TE regularly collect data from ginning mills, and also claims they have complete data on how much cotton comes into their own systems, but have “failed to take action on what they knew about the imbalance between the amount of organic cotton and the amount of organic textiles being made”.

But this allegation has been denied. In response to the New York Times article, TE said: “Organic cotton is a complex, multi-layered subject, and one that can quickly lose critical nuance when condensed into a single article. Without the right context, the piece risks undermining the importance of organic agriculture, while skipping over the solutions.”

But we’ve been here before. This is a problem.

Our own sources within certifiers have contrary opinions to TE. For example, they say they do not have the information from what TE calls “volume monitoring throughout the year”.

But this is information which TE suggests it has when it tells us: “Collecting data on the transactions of preferred materials bought and sold throughout the supply chain allows us to pinpoint with greater accuracy when and where there are mistakes or inconsistencies and address their route cause.”

When asked how it reconciles data for market reports, TE notes: “Since organic is governed by national and international standards, without recertifying all the farms to our own organic farming standard, we are not able to ‘verify’ global organic cotton production or what is happening on a farm.

“The organic cotton data that we collect through our various programmes have allowed us to identify weak links and inconsistencies in the supply chain. Solutions that are more straightforward (i.e., additional audits, additional data requisition for checking etc.) have already been put in place. Others, which are more complex and requires longer implementation timeframe (i.e., revision of standard, Trackit program etc.) is currently in progress.”

Surely though, reconciliation is checking for discrepancies, not recertifying? It means looking at the reports feeding into the market reports, at data in certification systems, checking totals in and out across all systems to see if they balance. Which is what was offered in 2014 with Check Organic.

Hermann claims that inertia defeated his attempts to get the organic cotton sector to try Check Organic back then.

Wryly, he adds: “I still believe Check Organic and GOTS would have been a perfect fit ... would have prevented the fraud as supply chains and quantities would have been known based on production data and yield.”

Exclusive Insight

  • Thursday, 05 December 2024

    Why worst-case data is better than average Premium Article

    Unless you’ve had your head in the sand for the past couple of years, you’ll have noticed that the world of textiles has suddenly become dominated by data – or more to the point, the lack of reliable data. There are now many well-meaning scores,…
  • Wednesday, 04 December 2024

    Weak links put EU textile recycling at risk Premium Article

    As the textile industry grapples with growing waste, the UK and EU textile recycling sectors faces unprecedented challenges, leading key players like Soex to succumb to insolvency just when they are needed the most. This market unpredictability…
  • Friday, 18 October 2024

    Lenzing boss aims to navigate economic headwinds Premium Article

    YORK – As he eases into his new role as the CEO of Lenzing, Rohit Aggarwal explains that despite market volatility and uncertainty in the textile sector, he welcomes more stringent environmental regulations, saying that textile-to-textile recycling…
  • Wednesday, 09 October 2024

    Traceable linen - bast of both worlds Premium Article

    With more brands sourcing linen in their spring collections this year, causing prices to triple in recent months, the European flax sector sees opportunities to offer fully traceable linen fabrics free from contamination with hemp or other bast…
  • Monday, 07 October 2024

    Bearing the brunt - Myanmar's garment workers Premium Article

    A combination of stagnant wages, soaring inflation and tumbling exchange rates has left garment workers in crisis-torn Myanmar facing huge challenges to meet even their most basic needs. The minimum wage for has been 4,800 kyat a day since 2018. The…
  • Thursday, 03 October 2024

    Recycled polyester innovation in good shape Premium Article

    North Carolina-based fibre innovator Unifi took some fibre industry experts by surprise when it launched a new 100% recycled filament polyester yarn with 50% textile content – a straightforward replacement for virgin polyester immediately available…
  • Wednesday, 02 October 2024

    From fast fashion – to immediate fashion Premium Article

    INDIA - Tech-driven ‘quick commerce’ is taking India by storm and with huge growth expected, western fashion brands are said to be in talks with platforms driving the immediate delivery of newly ordered goods. Gen Z and millennials in India’s top…
  • Tuesday, 01 October 2024

    Why the electrification of textile manufacturing needs more thought Premium Article

    YORK – The recent call by Fashion Revolution to rapidly electrify textile manufacturing operations through the implementation of renewables needs more careful consideration to avoid unintended rises in CO2 emissions. After several subjective…
  • Monday, 23 September 2024

    Aii and ZDHC plan CO2 and water guidelines Premium Article

    GLOBAL - Leading industry bodies Apparel Impact Institute (Aii) and the Zero Discharge of Hazardous Chemicals (ZDHC) are working on benchmark guidelines for both CO2 emissions and water use in garment and textile manufacturing facilities. Aii and…
  • Thursday, 19 September 2024

    Californian bill leads the charge on EPR Premium Article

    SACRAMENTO - The Sunshine State is poised to introduce a new Responsible Textile Recovery Act to combat unnecessary waste and promote the textile circular economy through new statutory measures. Regulators in California point to figures outlining…
Back Issue Archive
Other Publications from MCL News & Media

Interested in advertising?

Simply give us a call

Sales: +44 1977 708488

Or if you prefer email, click on the button below and we'll get back to you asap

 

Why Subscribe?

Founded in 2006, Ecotextile News is the environmental magazine for the global textile and fashion industries and provides unrivalled daily coverage, comment and expertise in both print and online formats.

Focused on sustainable innovation and industry best practice, subscribers enjoy:

What we offer:


    Thanks for sharing!
    Copy Link